Cookout Secret Menu: Hidden Items, Milkshake Hacks, and Smart Ordering Tips
The menu board at Cook Out only tells part of the story. Beyond the trays, burgers, and famous shakes, there’s a flexible ordering style that lets customers build custom combinations most people never even think to ask for.
The Cookout secret menu isn’t a printed list or an official promotion it’s all about smart customization. By mixing toppings, sides, and milkshake flavors, regular customers create “hidden” orders that feel exclusive, even though they’re made using the same everyday ingredients already on the menu.
The menu board at Cook Out only tells part of the story. Beyond the trays, burgers, and famous shakes, there’s a flexible ordering style that lets customers build custom combinations most people never even think to ask for.
The Cookout secret menu isn’t a printed list or an official promotion it’s all about smart customization. By mixing toppings, sides, and milkshake flavors, regular customers create “hidden” orders that feel exclusive, even though they’re made using the same everyday ingredients already on the menu.
What Is the Cookout Secret Menu?
The Cookout secret menu isn’t a real “hidden list” sitting behind the counter it exists because Cook Out’s menu is built for customization. With the way Cook Out is set up, you can easily adjust burgers, trays, sides, and milkshakes in ways that aren’t fully shown on the menu board.
What people call “secret” items are usually made from the exact same ingredients Cook Out already carries every day. There’s nothing magical being added behind the scenes just smart combinations, simple add-ons, and quick swaps that regular customers already know how to order.
In other words, the Cookout secret menu isn’t about memorizing special names. It’s about knowing how to ask clearly and customizing with confidence. Once you understand the ordering style, unlocking hidden favorites becomes easy.
Must-Try Cookout Secret Menu Items
Once you understand how customization works, the Cookout secret menu becomes much easier to unlock. These popular off-menu builds are made using regular Cook Out ingredients, which is why most locations can prepare them without any trouble.
The reason people love these “secret” orders is simple: they deliver more flavor, better balance, and often better value than ordering straight from the menu board. Think stacked burgers, upgraded hot dogs, and tray combos that feel truly personal not basic or standard.
Use the ideas below as inspiration. You don’t have to order them by a special name just clearly explain what you want added, swapped, or mixed. That’s the real secret.
Secret Main Dishes at a Cookout
The Cookout secret menu includes main dishes that may not be clearly listed on the menu board, but can usually be created using ingredients Cook Out already has in the kitchen. These “hidden” entrées are popular because they give you more control over flavor, spice, and texture without making your order complicated.
Instead of picking a standard build, you can upgrade a burger, customize a hot dog, or adjust toppings to match exactly what you’re craving. It’s a simple way to make your meal feel more personal while still ordering fast and easy.
Spicy Hot Dog (Firecracker Style)
If you’re craving something spicy, this custom hot dog is a simple but powerful upgrade. It’s typically built with chili, chopped onions, mustard, and a shake of Cajun seasoning for extra heat and bold flavor. Some locations may also have hot sauce available, so you can ask to add it if you want an even stronger kick.
This is one of the easiest “secret menu” style orders because the toppings are basic, common, and already used in many Cook Out items so most stores can make it without any hassle.
Everything-Style Burger
This is a fully loaded cheeseburger that takes a standard order and turns it into a “secret menu” style upgrade with extra toppings. Most people build it by adding chili, coleslaw, onions, pickles, lettuce, and tomato and some even go one step further by stacking onion rings on top for extra crunch.
It’s messy in the best possible way: rich, tangy, crunchy, and super filling. If you want a burger that feels like a complete meal by itself, this one delivers.
Peanut Butter Burger
This sweet-and-savory combo is exactly what it sounds like a regular burger with peanut butter added. Once it hits the warm patty, the peanut butter melts slightly, creating a creamy, salty bite that many Cook Out regulars genuinely love.
If you want to try it, keep your order simple and clear. Just ask for:
“A hamburger with peanut butter on it.”
It may sound unusual, but for a lot of fans, it’s one of those “don’t judge it until you try it” secret menu favorites.
BBQ Tray with Sandwich Slaw
This is a simple, value-packed customization that makes a BBQ tray feel even more complete. Order a BBQ tray and ask for coleslaw added directly on top of the BBQ sandwich (not just served on the side). The slaw adds a fresh crunch and a tangy balance that pairs perfectly with the smoky BBQ flavor.
It’s an easy upgrade, but it changes the whole bite in a really good way.
Mexi Dog
This is a bold, spicy hot dog upgrade that’s usually loaded with chili, diced onions, melted cheese, and hot sauce for extra heat. It’s basically a classic Cook Out hot dog taken to the next level messy, flavorful, and seriously satisfying.
To order it clearly, just say:
“Can I get a hot dog with chili, cheese, onions, and hot sauce?”
Simple, direct, and easy for most locations to make.
These “secret” main dishes aren’t hidden because they’re rare they’re considered secret because most people don’t realize how customizable Cook Out orders really are. Once you know you can mix toppings and build your own style, a lot more options open up.
The key is simple: order clearly. If you describe exactly what you want added or swapped, most Cook Out locations can make these custom builds without any trouble.
Cookout’s Secret Side Options
Beyond burgers and trays, the Cookout secret menu also includes side options that many customers either miss or don’t think to customize. Some sides aren’t always clearly promoted on the menu board, while others are “off-menu” favorites created by combining simple ingredients Cook Out already uses every day.
With a few quick add-ons, even a basic side can turn into a bigger, more satisfying part of your meal.
Grilled Cheese
One of the most common questions people ask is: Does Cook Out have grilled cheese?
In many locations, the answer is yes. A Cook Out grilled cheese is usually a simple, comforting item made with melted cheese on toasted bread or a bun-style build, depending on the location.
You can order it plain for a classic snack, or customize it if you want something more filling like adding tomato, extra cheese, or even a burger patty for a heartier, secret-menu style upgrade.
Fried Okra
Fried okra is a true Southern favorite, and while it may not be available at every Cook Out location, many stores can serve it when you ask. It’s crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and adds the perfect crunchy bite alongside BBQ trays or burgers.
If you want a side that feels classic, different, and full of comfort-food flavor, fried okra is a great “secret menu” style pick.
Hushpuppies
Hushpuppies are another Cook Out side that many people don’t realize they can order on their own or even add as part of a tray combo. These golden, fried cornmeal bites are crispy, comforting, and pair perfectly with savory mains like burgers or BBQ.
They add a nice crunch and help balance out richer, heavier flavors, making them a simple but underrated side upgrade.
Bacon and Grilled Onion Fries
This easy customization turns basic fries into a loaded, flavor-packed side by adding crispy bacon and smoky grilled onions on top. It’s simple, satisfying, and feels like a secret menu upgrade without being complicated.
To order it, just say:
“Can I get fries with bacon and grilled onions on top?”
It’s one of the easiest off-menu style sides to request, and it pairs perfectly with burgers and BBQ trays.
These “secret menu” side options work because they’re made with ingredients Cook Out already keeps in the kitchen every day. When you keep your request simple and explain what you want clearly, it’s easy to turn basic sides into standout upgrades that add more flavor and variety to your Cook Out meal.
Cookout Secret Milkshakes
Cook Out is famous for its milkshakes, and this is exactly where the Cookout milkshake secret menu truly stands out. Since shake flavors can be mixed together, customers can create custom combinations that aren’t officially listed but are still easy to order at most locations.
With the right mix, you can build a shake that tastes completely unique, even though it’s made using standard Cook Out flavors.
Mixed-Flavor Milkshakes
One of the best ways to order from the Cookout Secret Milkshakes menu is by mixing two flavors for a richer taste. Popular combos include Chocolate + Banana Pudding, Peanut Butter + Banana, Cherry + Chocolate, and Caramel + Oreo, which taste better than single-flavor shakes.
Cookout M&M Milkshake
Cookout M&M milkshake is perfect for people who love a crunchy texture in desserts. Just order a vanilla or chocolate milkshake with M&M pieces mixed in. For extra richness, you can add peanut butter or fudge, but the classic version usually tastes the most balanced.
Cookie and Candy Add-Ins
Besides Cookout’s standard flavors, many locations also let you customize your shake with cookie add-ins or candy add-ins like crushed cookies, candy pieces, or cheesecake bites. These simple extras can instantly turn a regular shake into a rich dessert-style treat without needing to order anything special.
The best rule for ordering secret milkshakes is to be clear and specific. Start by choosing a base flavor, then add one or two mix-ins for extra taste. Avoid overloading the shake so the flavors stay distinct, creamy, and perfectly balanced.
Secret Desserts at Cookout
In addition to milkshakes, the Cookout secret menu also includes a few dessert-style options that aren’t always easy to spot on the menu board. These items are usually made using existing ingredients and may only be available at select locations or during certain times of the year.
Brownie-Based Desserts
One of the best ways to order from the Cookout Secret Milkshakes menu is by mixing two flavors for a richer taste. Popular combos include Chocolate + Banana Pudding, Peanut Butter + Banana, Cherry + Chocolate, and Caramel + Oreo, which taste better than single-flavor shakes.
Cheesecake Add-Ons
Cookout M&M milkshake is perfect for people who love a crunchy texture in desserts. Just order a vanilla or chocolate milkshake with M&M pieces mixed in. For extra richness, you can add peanut butter or fudge, but the classic version usually tastes the most balanced.
These dessert options may not be available at every location, but if you ask politely and keep your order simple, you’ll have a much better chance of getting to try these lesser-known treats.
Create Your Own Unique Secret Menu Combination at Cookout
One of the best things about the Cookout secret menu is that it lets you truly build your own meal. Instead of sticking to pre-made combinations, you can mix and match your favorite mains, sides, toppings, and sauces to create something that fits your taste perfectly.
Start with a base item like a burger, hot dog, BBQ sandwich, chicken strips, or a tray. Then upgrade the flavor by adding extras such as slaw, chili, grilled onions, bacon, or even Cajun seasoning. Even small custom changes can make your order taste completely different and often much better.
Milkshakes work the same way. Start with a base flavor, add one or two mix-ins, and keep the blend balanced so no single taste takes over. When you treat the menu as flexible instead of fixed, it becomes easy to create a custom order that feels truly off-menu without making it complicated.
Hidden Side Combinations at Cookout
Some of the best values on the Cookout secret menu come from combining sides instead of ordering everything separately. These hidden side combinations may not be listed on the menu, but many people order them often because they add more variety and make a tray feel complete.
A simple trick is mixing sides inside your tray. Pairing fries with hushpuppies gives you a perfect mix of crunch and softness, while combining fries and okra (when available) adds contrast without extra cost. These combos go especially well with burgers and BBQ meals.
Another smart option is upgrading standard sides. Adding slaw, chili, bacon, or grilled onions to your fries or sandwich makes the side more filling and flavorful, without needing to order an extra item. These small changes are easy for the kitchen and can instantly improve both texture and flavor.
At the end of the day, these hidden side combos are all about balance mixing crispy, soft, salty, and tangy flavors to make every bite more satisfying without making your order complicated.
Secret Seasonal Offerings at Cookout
Some items on the Cookout secret menu are only available during certain times of the year. These seasonal offerings aren’t always promoted on the menu board, but they come and go depending on ingredient availability and what customers are asking for.
Most seasonal options show up in the Milkshakes menu. During fall, you may find flavors inspired by pumpkin or apple, while the warmer months often bring fruit-based mixes like strawberry or peach. You can usually order these flavors on their own or mix them with classic bases like vanilla or chocolate for a smoother, more familiar taste.
Because seasonal items can vary by location, the easiest approach is to simply ask which limited-time flavors or ingredients are currently available. The staff usually knows what short-run options people are ordering most, and one quick question can help you discover something new that isn’t shown on the menu board.
Tips to Order the Cookout Secret Menu
Ordering from the cookout secret menu becomes easy once you know the right approach. The main rule is to stay clear, realistic, and respectful while customizing your order.
Start with a regular menu item, then clearly explain the exact changes you want. Instead of asking for a “secret” item by name, simply list the toppings, sauces, or mix-ins you want added. This keeps things simple and helps the staff prepare your order without confusion.
It’s also smart to keep custom requests reasonable, especially during busy hours. Not every location can handle complicated changes when it’s crowded, so being patient really helps. A polite and straightforward request gives you the best chance of getting your order exactly how you want it.
Finally, keep in mind that availability can differ by location. If a certain ingredient or combination isn’t possible, just go with a simple alternative and enjoy the flexibility that makes the cookout secret menu fun in the first place.
My Personal Experience Ordering From the Cookout Secret Menu
I tried the Cookout secret menu after hearing so many people talk about how customizable Cookout really is. Honestly, the best part isn’t some “hidden item name,” it’s how easy it is to build your own flavor combo if you know what to ask for.
The first thing I noticed is that Cookout staff are usually fine with custom requests as long as you keep it simple and clear. I started with a basic tray order and upgraded it with small add-ons like chili, slaw, and grilled onions. Those little changes made my meal feel completely different without costing a lot more.
For milkshakes, mixing two flavors was easily my favorite trick. The texture and flavor came out better than most single-flavor shakes I’ve ordered before. After a few tries, I realized the secret menu isn’t about being “complicated” it’s just about being specific and balanced.
Overall, if you want to enjoy Cookout at its best, the secret menu style ordering is worth trying at least once especially if you like experimenting with flavors.
Real Feedback & Honest Food Reviews
The secret menu isn’t even hard you just ask for what you want. My go-to is a burger with chili and slaw. Perfect every time.
“I’m a milkshake person and Cookout is undefeated. Chocolate + Oreo is my favorite, but adding peanut butter makes it next level.
I asked the staff what seasonal flavors they had and they told me a limited-time option I didn’t see anywhere. Worth asking!
I used to order regular sides, but upgrading fries with bacon and grilled onions hits different. Simple and delicious.
(FAQs) People Also Ask About Cookout Secret Menu
Conclusion
The cookout secret menu isn’t about special passwords or “exclusive” items it’s simply about realizing how customizable Cook Out really is. When you start customizing mains, mixing sides, and blending milkshake flavors, you can build meals that feel way more exciting than what’s shown on the menu board.
Whether you’re going for a loaded burger, trying a custom grilled cheese, or experimenting with cookout secret milkshakes, even small changes can completely upgrade your order. The clearer and simpler you explain your customizations, the smoother the experience will be.
Once you treat the menu like a set of building blocks instead of fixed choices, Cook Out becomes a place where every visit can feel fresh, personal, and surprisingly fun.
Author Bio
About the Author – Michael Carter
Michael Carter is a U.S.-based food content researcher and fast-food menu analyst who specializes in reviewing restaurant pricing, nutrition data, and customer experience trends. His work focuses on accuracy, transparency, and helping readers make better dining choices.